Below is an analysis of the prospects in the farm system of the Colorado Rockies. Scouting reports were compiled with information provided by industry sources as well as my own observations. This is the fourth year we’re delineating between two anticipated relief roles, the abbreviations for which you’ll see in the “position” column below: MIRP for multi-inning relief pitchers, and SIRP for single-inning relief pitchers. The ETAs listed generally correspond to the year a player has to be added to the 40-man roster to avoid being made eligible for the Rule 5 draft. Manual adjustments are made where they seem appropriate, but we use that as a rule of thumb.
A quick overview of what FV (Future Value) means can be found here. A much deeper overview can be found here.
All of the ranked prospects below also appear on The Board, a resource the site offers featuring sortable scouting information for every organization. It has more details (and updated TrackMan data from various sources) than this article and integrates every team’s list so readers can compare prospects across farm systems. It can be found here.
Other Prospects of Note
Grouped by type and listed in order of preference within each category.
Depth Starters
Karl Kauffmann, RHP
Tanner Gordon, RHP
Blake Adams, RHP
Victor Juarez, RHP
Kauffmann made his big league debut last year and was a few roster days away from losing rookie status. The Rockies removed him from the 40-man during the offseason, but he’s still pretty likely to be called upon as depth here during his prime. He throws a one-seam sinker and a plus slider, but his stuff is a little light to grab a roster spot permanently. Gordon was as part of the Pierce Johnson trade with Atlanta, and could have reasonably been projected as a spot starter at the time of the swap. The Rockies left him off the 40-man roster during the offseason. He’s a five-pitch righty with a good slider. He touched 96 during his lone Cactus League start and then began the year on the IL. Adams is a four-pitch guy whose arm slot creates a big fastball/curveball split. Juarez is a stout, advanced little righty with 40-grade stuff at High-A.
Hittable Fastball Shapes
Riley Pint, RHP
Brayan Castillo, RHP
Jake Madden, RHP
Pint’s velo is down a bit this spring. It’s one thing to live with his wildness at 97-99 mph and another when he’s averaging 93-95, which has been the case so far this year. His slider is still great. The same is true for Castillo, who also throws pretty hard but without effectual movement. I wonder if he could lean into sink with a different org. Madden, acquired from the Angels in the C.J. Cron/Randal Grichuk deal last year, has a prototypical pitcher’s build at lanky 6-foot-6. He also has mid-90s arm strength, but it tails into barrels and Madden’s secondary stuff has not progressed as hoped when he was drafted out of Northwest Florida State.
Funky Lefties
Evan Justice, LHP
Alberto Pacheco, LHP
Justice is a drop-and-drive lefty with the stuff to be a good reliever (huge slider, sitting 95), but nowhere near the control. Pacheco is a little bit younger, sits 93, and has an above-average changeup.
Hit Tool Only Guys
Jameson Hannah, OF
Ronaiker Palma, C
Bairon Ledesma, 2B
This is a pretty self-explanatory group. Hannah has performed well at the upper levels but has so little power that he’s probably only destined for a cup of coffee. I’ve been a Palma fan for a while (plus arm, super twitchy little guy, absurd contact rates), but he barely plays. Ledesma is part of the extended spring training group up from last year’s DSL. He’s an undersized infielder with feel for the barrel.
Toolsy Guys on the Fringe
Ryan Ritter, SS
Warming Bernabel, 3B
Andy Perez, 1B
Erick Bautista, OF
Ritter, currently at Hartford, looks like he can play shortstop in most situations except when a play needs to be made quickly, which occurs a lot at the major league level. He has a 30 hit tool and 40 power. Bernabel has been undone by injuries and a reckless approach. His hitting hands have lost a little bit of juice, as well. He was once a potential third baseman of the future. Perez has plus physical projection and fantastic feel to hit for a young guy his size, but he’s one of the most swing-happy hitters in all of pro baseball. Bautista is a very physical power-hitting 19-year-old outfielder with strikeout issues. He’s part of the Arizona complex group.
System Overview
This system has above-average overall depth, as well as a sizable contingent of prospects who one could consider “high-upside” or of potential impact in the 40+ FV tier and above. What it lacks is a trajectory-altering franchise player, let alone the couple of them the Rockies would likely need to catch up to the heavy hitters in the NL West anytime soon. I’ve seen Antonio Senzatela and Germán Márquez in a sweat-soaked post-workout glow hanging out to watch extended spring training games. Either of them is a potential deadline trade target who could add to Colorado’s prospect coffers.
The Rockies’ international scouting group has kept this system flush with very exciting youngsters for the last handful of seasons. As those young players mature and climb the minors, sometimes warts that threaten their profile pop up, as with Warming Bernabel’s and Yanquiel Fernandez’s lack of plate discipline. Once again, there is a large contingent of exciting players in the low minors who will now filter up through minor league offensive environments that might cause your friendly neighborhood prospect writer to overrate their ability. Basically every Rockies affiliate (especially Spokane) is friendly towards hitters in a prominent way. That makes sense from a dev standpoint because so too is these prospects’ ultimate destination. But it can make it tougher to properly assess those hitters’ true talent when their inflated surface-level performance is the easiest thing for hungry Rockies fans to see, creating unrealistic expectations for guys like Michael Toglia, Elehuris Montero, and others. In the same way I was skeptical of those guys, there are a few hitters who Rockies fans and fantasy players should be cautious about overrating. I like Jordan Beck etc., just not as much as other evaluators, including plenty of actual scouts.
The gist of the Rockies, once again, is that the org seems quite good at scouting but not at developing. It can also be chaotic just trying to scout the Rockies due to the org’s idiosyncrasies, which can sometimes include struggling to get rosters and dealing with unannounced changes to start times. Stuff like this has happened again this spring. Last week, the Rockies moved their start times without telling anyone except their opponent — including, in one instance, the umpires. We called balls and strikes off the Trackman unit until the crew arrived closer to the originally scheduled time. These are petty frustrations that have greater impact on opposing scouts (and media) than the Rockies, and if you want to argue in favor of espionage rather than for professional courtesy I suppose you can, but to the scouts whose coverage has been affected by stuff like this, it’s a microcosm of other issues keeping the Rockies sunk.
Source
https://blogs.fangraphs.com/colorado-rockies-top-47-prospects-2024/