Below is an analysis of the prospects in the farm system of the Milwaukee Brewers. Scouting reports were compiled with information provided by industry sources as well as my own observations. This is the fourth year we’re delineating between two anticipated relief roles, the abbreviations for which you’ll see in the “position” column below: MIRP for multi-inning relief pitchers, and SIRP for single-inning relief pitchers. The ETAs listed generally correspond to the year a player has to be added to the 40-man roster to avoid being made eligible for the Rule 5 draft. Manual adjustments are made where they seem appropriate, but we use that as a rule of thumb.
A quick overview of what FV (Future Value) means can be found here. A much deeper overview can be found here.
All of the ranked prospects below also appear on The Board, a resource the site offers featuring sortable scouting information for every organization. It has more details (and updated TrackMan data from various sources) than this article and integrates every team’s list so readers can compare prospects across farm systems. It can be found here.
Other Prospects of Note
Grouped by type and listed in order of preference within each category.
Present Power or Power Projection
Ernesto Martinez, 1B
Wes Clarke, 1B
Pedro Tovar, RF
Idalberto Santiesteban, LF
Jesus Chirinos, 1B
Luis Castillo, LF
Zavier Warren, 1B
The 6-foot-5, 250-pound Martinez has never quite been able to tap into his considerable raw power via launch, but he has cut his strikeouts enough to be interesting again. He has better contact rates, measurable power, and long-term athletic projection than Clarke, who was a good college hitter at South Carolina. Clarke swings and misses an awful lot for a first base prospect but has comfortably plus raw power. Tovar and Santiesteban are lanky DSL youngsters with room for big strength. Tovar’s bat speed is already exciting, but he’s underneath a ton of high pitches. Santiesteban isn’t as explosive, but he has the more stable hit tool of the two. Chirinos, a 22-year-old former catcher, has above-average power, but it isn’t actualized enough in games to make up for his lack of hit tool. Castillo and Warren have more balanced contact/power blends but neither is plus, making it tough for them to profile at their current positions.
Contact-Oriented Infielders
Freddy Zamora, SS
Luis Lameda, 3B
Demetrio Nadal, UTIL
Kevin Ereu, SS
Zamora was an early draft pick out of Miami because of his contact and defense. He’s fallen behind the age/level pace in part because of injuries, and is also less crisp on defense than I previously thought — this is a guy with a poor internal clock who approaches balls too slowly. Lameda is a switch-hitting 18-year-old third baseman with good feel for contact. He’s a little less physically gifted than the DSL infielders who made the main section of the list, but he still has a prospect-y skill foundation and should be monitored for growth. Nadal had a huge 2023 in his second DSL season (which makes it tougher to contextualize those numbers) while playing all over the diamond. He has a pull- and lift-heavy approach already. Ereu was a $1.4 million bonus prospect from two signing periods ago whose bat looked rough in his DSL debut. He can pick it, though.
Upper-Level Pitching Depth
Chad Patrick, RHP
Aidan Maldonado, RHP
Nick Merkel, RHP
Ryan Middendorf, RHP
Blake Holub, RHP
Russell Smith, LHP
Justin Yeager, RHP
Yorman Galindez, RHP
A 2021 fourth round pick by Arizona, Patrick has been traded a couple of times in the last year, first for Jace Peterson and then for Abraham Toro. He has a five-pitch mix headlined by a good cutter, and could be a spot starter. Maldonado, 23, is a funkadelic righty from Minnesota with a good changeup. His workload trended down throughout last year and he may come out as a pure reliever in 2024. If so, look for a velo spike above his current 91-92 mph. Merkel is a 6-foot-7 25-year-old undrafted out of Central Methodist. He has huge extension and a plus slider, but only sat about 90-91 last year. Yeager, Holub, Middendorf, and Smith is a law firm of acceptable depth relievers. Middendorf is a low-slot groundball guy, Holub is a vert-slot riding fastball type, and Smith is a lefty with a good slider. Yeager was hurt for most of last year, but is a wild upper-80s slider guy when healthy. Galindez, 21, has had bat-missing success as a swingman in the lower levels while sitting 92-93 with a good curveball. His hips are loose and he gets down the mound pretty well, which helps the line on his fastball stay shallow.
System Overview
This is a pretty deep system, though some of my biases as an evaluator/scout/analyst are probably to thank for that, as I tend to gravitate towards the same kind of hitters Milwaukee does: contact-driven little guys at up-the-middle positions. While it has plus depth from top to bottom, the depth in the impact tier (40+ FV tier and above) is closer to average and maybe even a little bit below. Keep in mind that Milwaukee has traded away eight prospects during the offseason (most of them fringy); this list would probably be a few names deeper if not for that. There is a nice mix of short-term and potential long-term impact in this system, and I think that’s true even though I’m bearish on Tyler Black and want to see a little more from Brock Wilken before I move him into the top 100.
The Brewers have a few transactional patterns aside from just their preference for the little hit tool guys. They pick a ton of junior college or small school players, especially pitchers, and develop them. This list is populated with guys like that for the third straight year, and there are some 2023 draftees (like Jason Woodward and Ryan Birchard) who might show similar improvement in the coming season. Milwaukee’s international scouting operation tends to do well in Venezuela more often than in other places (three of the top six players in the system are from there), but the Brewers’ top two 2024 signees were from the Dominican Republic, and they’ve signed several pitchers from Nicaragua in the last couple of years.
The Corbin Burnes trade (DL Hall would be ranked somewhere in the Wilken-Josh Knoth range were he eligible for the list) was the second seller-postured blockbuster the Brewers have made during the last three seasons, with the Josh Hader deal being the other. In both instances they got back multiple prospects, but aside from Joey Ortiz fitting their contact-oriented tendencies, the types of players they’ve gotten in those deals have run the gamut. It seems that periodic trades like this are part of the way Brewers ownership is inclined to operate given their market size.
Source
https://blogs.fangraphs.com/milwaukee-brewers-top-42-prospects/